AlphaGen
Access AlphaGen
Company Explained

First Treet Manufacturing Modaraba: The Trade-Off Between Packaging Scale and Soap Margins

First Treet Manufacturing Modaraba combines a high-volume, thin-margin packaging business with higher-margin soap—and faces a growing cash-conversion test.

Aug 28, 2026FTMMShare price, results & dividends

Company in 30 seconds

Company Name: First Treet Manufacturing Modaraba

Ticker: FTMM

First Treet Manufacturing Modaraba is a listed, perpetual Modaraba managed by Treet Holdings Limited. After transferring its battery undertaking to Treet Battery Limited, it is now a two-segment manufacturer: corrugated packaging and soap. Packaging supplies industrial customers that need boxes; soap serves a value-sensitive consumer market, with production outsourced under a toll-manufacturing arrangement. Official corporate profile.

FTMM earns the spread between selling prices and the costs of materials, conversion, distribution and overhead. Packaging supplies most revenue but currently earns very thin margins; soap is smaller and higher-margin but more exposed to raw-material inflation and consumer price sensitivity. In the nine months ended March 31, 2026, revenue rose while operating and net profit fell, making margin and cash conversion more important than sales growth alone.

What matters most

  • Packaging price discipline: corrugated boxes represented roughly three-quarters of FY2025 revenue. New industry capacity and aggressive pricing can lift volumes while leaving little operating profit, so customer selection and product mix matter as much as tonnes sold. FY2025 segment review.
  • Soap input costs and pricing: soap has the higher gross-margin profile, but value-conscious consumers and raw-material inflation constrain pass-through. In the latest nine months, soap sales grew while gross profit fell. March 2026 segment review.
  • Receivable conversion: trade debts rose by almost Rs398 million in nine months. Revenue that is not collected absorbs liquidity and can turn accounting growth into a cash constraint. March 2026 cash flow and balance sheet.
  • Capital allocation: FTMM spent Rs126.7 million on property, plant and equipment and paid Rs293.4 million of interim distribution during the nine months, while cash fell to Rs101.0 million. The balance among maintenance, growth spending and payouts is therefore central. March 2026 cash-flow statement.
  • Group relationships: Treet Corporation and Treet Holdings control virtually all certificates, and FTMM sells to, advances funds to and earns finance income from related parties. These flows can support utilization and income, but they must be separated from the economics of external customers. FY2025 related-party notes.

Key facts and figures

  • FTMM was formed on July 27, 2005 as a multipurpose, perpetual and multidimensional Modaraba and is managed by Treet Holdings Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary of Treet Corporation Limited. Legal status.
  • The battery undertaking was demerged and transferred to Treet Battery Limited under a court-sanctioned scheme during FY2024; current reports identify only corrugated boxes and soap as operating segments. FY2025 audited report.
  • At June 30, 2025, Treet Corporation held 97.11% of certificate capital and Treet Holdings held another 2.22%, leaving a very small outside holding. Certificate-capital note.
  • The packaging facility is at Kacha Tiba Rohi Nala, 22-KM Ferozepur Road, Lahore; the soap location is at Ghakkar Mandi, Gujranwala. Company locations.
  • FY2025 corrugated-box rated capacity was 30,000 tonnes and production was 17,716 tonnes, implying about 59% utilization. Soap production was 2,124 tonnes; capacity is not disclosed because production shifted to toll manufacturing from July 1, 2021. Capacity note.
  • FY2025 net sales were Rs3.793 billion, down 9% year on year. Packaging supplied 77.67% of revenue and soap 22.33%; all sales were to customers in Pakistan. FY2025 audited results.
  • For the nine months to March 31, 2026, net revenue was Rs2.994 billion, up 4.6% from Rs2.863 billion. Gross profit fell 7.7% to Rs248.2 million and operating profit fell 48.9% to Rs60.2 million. Unaudited nine-month accounts.
  • Nine-month profit after tax was Rs89.4 million, down 21.4% from Rs113.7 million; earnings per certificate were Rs0.46 versus Rs0.58. Unaudited nine-month accounts.
  • Packaging revenue for those nine months was Rs2.207 billion, up 3%, but segment operating profit dropped to Rs6.5 million from Rs30 million. March 2026 directors’ report.
  • Soap revenue was Rs787 million, up 9%, while gross profit declined to Rs146 million from Rs155 million as management cited elevated raw-material costs. March 2026 directors’ report.
  • At March 31, 2026, trade debts were Rs1.201 billion, cash Rs101.0 million and taxes recoverable or adjustable Rs1.208 billion; total assets were Rs3.823 billion. March 2026 financial position.
  • Nine-month operating cash flow was positive Rs48.2 million, capital expenditure was Rs126.7 million and the interim distribution was Rs293.4 million, or Rs1.50 per certificate. March 2026 cash flow and equity statement.

How the business model works

Corrugated packaging: scale without guaranteed margin

Corrugated packaging converts paper-based inputs into boxes designed around customers’ dimensions, strength, printing and delivery requirements. Economically, the segment earns a conversion spread: selling price less paper and other material costs, energy, labor, maintenance, wastage and freight. FTMM’s filings do not disclose the full procurement basket or import share, so direct FX exposure should not be assumed; nevertheless, paper-linked input prices and energy costs are logical operating sensitivities for this process. Packaging project and audited segment disclosure.

This is usually an industrial, relationship-led sale rather than a simple retail product. Reliability, print quality, box strength, delivery timing and the ability to serve larger accounts can protect business, but excess capacity makes price competition severe. FTMM’s FY2025 packaging revenue fell 3% to Rs2.737 billion, yet gross margin improved from 3% to 4% and the segment moved from an operating loss to Rs30.0 million profit after cost reduction. That was progress, but a 1% operating margin left little cushion. FY2025 segment analysis.

The latest period shows how quickly that cushion can disappear. Packaging revenue grew 3% in the nine months to March 2026, while operating profit fell nearly four-fifths to Rs6.5 million. Management attributes the squeeze to aggressive industry pricing and more price-sensitive customers, and says it is focusing on cost rationalization, disciplined customer selection, strategic-client retention and product mix. Those are management objectives, not guaranteed outcomes. March 2026 management review.

Soap: higher margin, different route to market

Soap is a consumer-products business with different economics. Brand visibility, product availability, distributor incentives, pack sizes and retail price points matter alongside formulation and manufacturing cost. FTMM moved production to toll manufacturing in July 2021, so disclosed output no longer represents utilization of an owned rated soap capacity. The arrangement can reduce fixed manufacturing intensity, but profitability still depends on procurement, tolling cost, distribution and the ability to pass input inflation to value-sensitive buyers. FY2025 capacity and segment notes.

In FY2025, soap sales fell 21% to Rs1.057 billion. Gross margin edged up from 21% to 22%, but operating margin dropped from 17% to 12%, and management linked the weakness to intense competition in value-sensitive segments and greater marketing activity. In the first half of FY2026, soap revenue recovered 7% to Rs587 million while gross profit fell 8%, an early warning that sales growth was being bought at a lower unit contribution. December 2025 half-year report.

That pattern continued through March: nine-month soap revenue rose 9% to Rs787 million, yet gross profit declined about 6% to Rs146 million. Management identified raw-material costs as the cause and described pricing, cost management, penetration and distribution availability as its responses. AlphaGen’s inference is that soap currently provides the group’s margin pool, but that pool is vulnerable when price increases lag input costs or consumers trade down. March 2026 segment review.

Customers, route to market and concentration

FTMM reported that all FY2025 sales were domestic. In packaging, it disclosed Rs319.5 million of sales to Pepsi-Cola International Pakistan and Rs401.4 million to Continental Biscuits; together they represented about 26% of packaging revenue. The soap segment disclosed Rs109.6 million of sales to Karam Elahi Traders. These figures show both the value of anchor accounts and the collection and bargaining risks that can accompany concentration. FY2025 customer disclosure.

Packaging appears to use direct account management for industrial customers, while soap requires broader market penetration and distribution availability. The public filings do not provide distributor counts, brands by revenue or regional market shares, so claims about national reach would be speculative. Readers should instead track disclosed segment sales, major-customer concentration, receivable days and management’s evidence of new accounts. Official company and segment disclosures.

Revenue, costs and the margin bridge

The nine-month comparison is mixed. Revenue rose Rs131.0 million, but cost of revenue increased Rs151.8 million, so gross profit fell Rs20.8 million. Gross margin declined from about 9.4% to 8.3%. Administrative expense increased 45.8% to Rs50.1 million and distribution cost rose 18.3% to Rs124.4 million, pulling operating margin from roughly 4.1% to 2.0%. March 2026 profit-and-loss statement.

Other income of Rs57.3 million was almost as large as operating profit and helped lift profit before levies and tax. In FY2025, a substantial part of other income came from profit on advances to Treet Corporation and Treet Battery Limited, plus bank returns. This income is real under the reported arrangements, but it is economically distinct from selling boxes or soap and should be analyzed separately when judging recurring operating performance. FY2025 other-income note.

Balance sheet and cash conversion

The most important balance-sheet move is the increase in trade debts from Rs802.4 million at June 2025 to Rs1.201 billion at March 2026. That 49.6% rise was far faster than nine-month sales growth and consumed Rs398.3 million of working capital. Trade and other payables increased by Rs339.2 million to Rs977.9 million, partially financing the receivable build. March 2026 financial position and cash flow.

Operating cash flow was positive Rs48.2 million, an improvement from negative Rs123.3 million in the comparable period, but it remained modest against Rs89.4 million of profit and Rs126.7 million of capital spending. After the Rs293.4 million interim distribution, cash fell by Rs368.4 million to Rs101.0 million. This does not by itself imply distress—current assets still exceeded current liabilities—but it reduces the buffer against slower collections or another cost shock. March 2026 cash-flow statement.

Taxes recoverable or adjustable reached Rs1.208 billion, nearly one-third of total assets. At FY2025, the balance included sales tax adjustable and income tax refundable amounts. Recovery and utilization timing therefore matter to asset quality and liquidity even though the balance is not a conventional customer receivable. FY2025 tax-recoverable note.

At June 2025, FTMM had Rs556.3 million of advances to Treet Corporation and Treet Battery Limited for working-capital needs, carrying markup at FTMM’s weighted average cost of capital. The annual report also recorded sales of corrugated boxes to Treet Corporation and Renacon Pharma, finance income from group advances, management fees to Treet Holdings and outsourced employee services from Treet HR Management. The accounts say related-party transactions use admissible arm’s-length valuation methods; readers should still reconcile these flows because they can materially affect cash and earnings. FY2025 related-party disclosure.

Favorable and adverse operating environments

FTMM’s favorable environment combines disciplined packaging pricing, higher utilization without discounting, stable input costs, soap growth with timely price pass-through, faster collections and controlled distribution spending. Under those conditions, spare packaging capacity can provide operating leverage while soap preserves the margin pool.

The adverse case combines price competition, soap inputs rising faster than retail pricing, slower collections and cash outlays exceeding operating cash. The March 2026 accounts show several of these pressures together: higher sales, thinner margins, a receivable build and lower cash.

Structural strengths and risks

  • Structural strengths include two distinct revenue engines, established industrial accounts, an installed packaging platform with spare capacity, a toll-manufactured soap model that limits the need to disclose owned rated capacity, and backing from the wider Treet group. FY2025’s audited accounts also showed positive operating cash flow, and the Modaraba remained profitable through the latest competitive squeeze. FY2025 and March 2026 reports.
  • Margin risk is the most immediate weakness: packaging operating profit was only Rs6.5 million on Rs2.207 billion of nine-month revenue, while soap gross profit fell despite higher sales. Small pricing or cost movements can therefore have an outsized effect on earnings. March 2026 segment results.
  • Working-capital risk has increased because trade debts expanded much faster than sales and cash declined sharply. Customer concentration adds collection and negotiating exposure, even when counterparties are well-established. March 2026 and FY2025 disclosures.
  • Related-party and capital-allocation risk requires scrutiny because group advances, finance income, sales, service fees and funding flows are material. The interim distribution also exceeded operating cash generation. Official related-party and cash-flow notes.
  • Information risk remains: the filings do not disclose product-level volumes, average selling prices, full input sourcing, import content, brand economics or market share. Analysis must avoid filling those gaps with invented precision. Official reporting archive.

Growth avenues—and what would prove them

Management’s stated packaging levers are cost rationalization, strategic-account retention, disciplined customer selection and better mix; spare capacity allows growth without an immediate new line, but only if contribution and collections improve. In soap, pricing, procurement, visibility and channel availability must rebuild volume without sacrificing gross profit.

How to read this company’s results

  • Segment revenue and profit: separate packaging from soap. Consolidated sales can grow even while the mix shifts toward lower-margin business.
  • Gross margin and operating margin: packaging’s current margin is exceptionally thin; soap’s gross margin is the key buffer against group overhead.
  • Packaging tonnes and utilization: compare production with the 30,000-tonne rated base, but demand evidence that higher utilization is not driven by destructive pricing.
  • Trade debts and cash collected: compare receivable growth with sales and track operating cash flow after working-capital changes.
  • Other income: distinguish bank returns and profit on related-party advances from earnings generated by boxes and soap.
  • Distribution and administration costs: test whether marketing and route-to-market spending produces durable segment revenue and margin.
  • Taxes recoverable and group advances: these balances are assets, but their timing and liquidity differ from cash.
  • Capital expenditure and distributions: compare both with operating cash flow to judge whether the cash buffer is rebuilding or shrinking.

What to monitor

  • Packaging segment operating margin, price discipline and evidence that customer mix is improving.
  • Soap gross profit and margin, not revenue growth alone, as the test of raw-material pass-through.
  • Trade debts, collection days and cash generated from operations relative to reported profit.
  • Packaging production versus 30,000-tonne rated capacity and the return on recent capital expenditure.
  • The cash balance after working-capital needs, capital spending and any further distribution.
  • Taxes recoverable or adjustable and the pace at which those balances are utilized or refunded.
  • Related-party advances, finance income, sales and service charges, with terms and cash settlement.
  • Customer concentration, additions to strategic accounts and whether volume growth comes with sustainable pricing.

Sources

Explore more research

All articles